Should You Pay for a Straight-to-Sim Funded Account or Go Through an Evaluation?

If you’re trading the futures market (e.g., ES, NQ, CL) using a prop firm, you’ve likely faced this question: Should I go through an evaluation phase or pay more upfront for a straight-to-sim funded account?

As someone who actively trades and manages multiple prop accounts, I’ve been testing both approaches. In this post, we’ll walk through the pros and cons, break down real-world costs using Tradeify and Bulenox as examples, and explore a strategy where you hedge two evaluation accounts to boost your chances of getting funded.

Two Paths to Get Funded

While not all prop firms offer it, there’s been a growing trend in recent years to introduce straight-to-sim funded accounts alongside the traditional evaluation path. Both options can ultimately lead to a sim funded trading account, but the structure, cost, and rules can vary significantly. Understanding how these two paths differ—and which aligns better with your strategy—can help you make a more cost-effective decision.

• Evaluation Phase – You pay a smaller upfront fee, meet a profit target (typically around $3,000 for a 50K account), and pay an activation fee to start trading with your sim funded account.
• Straight-to-Sim Funded – You skip the evaluation entirely and start with a sim funded account. These come at a much higher upfront cost, but you avoid the stress of passing an evaluation.

⚠️ Important Note: Straight-to-sim funded accounts often carry slightly stricter rules than the evaluation path. For example, in the Tradeify model, the straight-to-sim funded account introduces a Daily Loss Limit (Soft Breach) of $1,250, which does not apply to the evaluation path or the subsequent sim funded account.

Comparing Evaluation Costs: Tradeify vs. Bulenox

To get a realistic sense of what each path might cost you, it’s important to look at both the account features and the actual out-of-pocket costs under different scenarios. Below are two tables: one that compares the features side-by-side, and one that breaks down total costs depending on whether you’re using discounts or need resets.

Evaluation Account Features Side-by-Side

This table shows how Tradeify’s Advanced Evaluation compares to Bulenox’s Evaluation program in terms of structure, contract limits, fees, and payout rules:

Evaluation Cost Scenarios

Here’s what you might actually pay depending on discounts and how many resets you need. These examples assume a single evaluation account, one activation, and either zero, one, or two resets.

Comparing Straight-to-Sim Funded Accounts

Straight-to-sim funded accounts offer instant access to a simulated funded account—no need to pass an evaluation. But they usually come with a higher upfront cost and sometimes stricter rules than the standard evaluation path.

Straight-to-Funded Account Features: Tradeify Example

This table shows Tradeify’s straight-to-sim funded accounts in terms of structure, contract limits, fees, and payout rules:

⚠️ Note: Unlike the evaluation path, this straight-to-sim funded account includes a daily loss limit—something not present in the evaluation or post-evaluation funded accounts. Always read the rules before jumping in.

The Hedged Strategy: Go Long in One, Short in the Other

Here’s a potentially cost-effective approach that some traders use: Buy two evaluation accounts, take opposing trades (long in one, short in the other), and try to pass at least one. If one account hits the profit target, you pay the activation fee and go live. If the other fails, you’re out just a reset fee.

Hedged Strategy Cost Example: 2 Evaluations

To put the hedging strategy into perspective, let’s break down the actual costs of running two discounted evaluation accounts—one long, one short. This tactic is designed to increase your odds of passing at least one account, but there’s no guarantee. Below is a cost estimate assuming you activate only the passing account and cancel the one that fails:

Cost Comparison Formula

Once you understand the structure and fees of each path, the next step is comparing what you’ll likely spend. Whether you’re leaning toward a straight-to-funded account or experimenting with a hedged evaluation strategy, use this simple formula to quickly estimate which route makes more financial sense based on your situation:

Hedged Strategy Cost = (2 × Monthly Fee) + Activation Fee  
Straight-to-Funded Cost = One-Time Upfront Fee

If Hedged Strategy Cost ≥ Straight-to-Funded Cost:  
 → Go with Straight-to-Funded  
Else:  
 → Go with Hedged Evaluation Strategy

⚠️ Important Note: There is no guarantee the hedged strategy will work. There’s always the chance that both accounts could be blown, leaving you with no funded account and the need to try again. Use this strategy only if you understand the risks and have strong trade management in place.

Quick Comparison Example

If you’re deciding purely based on cost and assuming one evaluation account passes and the other is simply canceled, here’s how the hedged strategy stacks up against a straight-to-funded option:

💡 Takeaway: If you successfully execute the hedged strategy, you could save $100–$150 (per sim funded account) compared to paying for a straight-to-sim funded account.

What’s the Best Option?

There’s no single right answer—it really depends on your goals, experience, and how you trade under pressure. But this might help you think about your options:

• Still developing consistency? The evaluation path is budget-friendly and gives you the structure to practice with rules that mirror a real account. It’s a solid option if you’re working on discipline or testing a new setup.
• Ready to skip the wait and just trade? A straight-to-sim funded account is ideal if you’re confident in your edge and just want to start executing. Just make sure you fully understand any additional rules, like daily loss limits, that aren’t part of the evaluation phase.
• Looking to game the system a bit? Buying two discounted eval accounts and running a long/short hedge can be a smart tactic, although not guaranteed to succeed. It increases your odds of passing one and keeps your overall costs low.

Final Thoughts

No matter which route you choose, the key is knowing what you’re paying for—and what’s expected of you once you’re “funded.”

Whatever you do, calculate your total cost—including resets and activation fees—and always check for current promos. Choose the path that fits your capital, mindset, and confidence in your setup.

🎉 Prop Trading Discounts

💥91% off at Bulenox.com with the code MDT91